Book Reviews
May 2024
The Word for World is Forest
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
The Word for World is Forest is set in the distant future when humans have depleted Earth of most of its natural resources. Having nothing on the ground, they look to the stars. In their exploration of space, these future humans have found a world of abundance with plenty of trees to clearcut and send back home where the vast majority of trees have gone extinct. This world even has a peaceful species of helpers that humans have “recruited” to help, keeping them in pens and treating them as animals. As the story unfolds, it becomes clear how much destruction humans have wrought to this new world, their home world, and the societies of both.
Le Guin does not pull punches in her criticism of imperialist and industrial attitudes concerning the destruction of natural habitats for human resource “needs.” The story is told from three points of view to grasp the full scope of the events occurring as humans invoke their Manifest Destiny and take what they believe is theirs. The first point of view is hard to stomach as it is the viewpoint of someone justifying this destruction, fixated on humans deserving everything they can take by force. The other two PoVs see the desecration of nature for what it is and actively oppose the mistreatment of the planet’s ecosystems and life. As the story unfolds, the reader sees the impact of what seems to be surface-level destruction and how it changes life on this new planet, potentially forever. While this novella takes place on a distant planet, it is evident that the anger and frustration the text evokes are aimed closer to home.
April 2024
The Parable of the Sower by Octavia Butler
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
The Parable of the Sower falls somewhere between dystopian and apocalyptic climate fiction. The story is told through journal entries by a young woman named Lauren who seeks a deeper truth and understanding of the world as society collapses around her into violence and ruin. An additional hurdle our protagonist has to overcome is a rare condition called “hyperempathy,” where she literally feels the pain of other people and even some animals. Through determination and encouragement from her father, she has trained herself not to show this affliction or tell others around her. The world is dangerous enough without showing any possible weakness.
One of the most disconcerting things about this book is that while it was published just over 30 years ago, it begins in 2024. It takes place in California, beginning in a walled neighborhood near Los Angeles that provides Lauren and her family refuge from the violence that afflicts the outside world. We get insights into this world’s “normal” through Lauren’s journal entries, her reflections on the way things should be in opposition to how they are, and conversations she has with friends and family. This story is incredibly relevant to today’s current events, to the point that many people have touted it as “prophetic” as more and more resources have been privatized in Laurens world, to the point that neighbors deal with fires and crime themselves to save the money they would have to pay for these services.
This book is dark, harrowing, and hard to read at times. While it is understandable why it is called a sci-fi classic, I would recommend anyone considering this book as their next read to be aware of its content warnings.
March 2024
The Bone Clocks by David Mitchell
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
The Bone Clocks is a unique novel made up of several vignettes that take place between 1984 and 2043. The first introduces the teenage Holly Sykes who has a rebellious streak and an odd connection to her “daydreams,” which presented as auditory hallucinations when she was a child. As each vignette unfolds, we learn more about these “hallucinations” and the part they play in the character’s lives, the world, and potentially the future of the human race.
While I don’t know if everybody would consider this book “climate fiction,” climate change does play a significant role in the setting and motivation of the characters as the vignettes close in on the year 2043. Each vignette is told from a different perspective with a loose throughline of a few connecting characters. These points of view vary in life experiences, values, ages, and motivations. This style of storytelling could potentially be jarring for some readers, especially as each vignette does have loose connections to the others. It took some getting used to, but Mitchell’s writing was compelling enough that I was immersed in the story quickly after every perspective shift and time jump.
February 2024
The Book of Koli by M.R. Carey
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
The Book of Koli is the first book of a trilogy set in a future England that is barely recognizable with trees that actively attack people and where all current knowledge appears to be lost, a boy named Koli takes the reader on a journey where they get to learn more about his world, and he learns what happened to ours. In this future, technology is misunderstood, perceived as almost magical, and often erratic, sometimes awakening and responding to the future leaders of Koli’s village, sometimes swooping in at random to attack and kill villagers. Warfare and climate disasters have significantly reduced the population of “Ingland,” making population pockets small with fewer healthy babies coming into the world every year. Things aren’t looking great.
This story is told from a first-person perspective from the point of view of an illiterate teenage boy. Because of this, the writing style may turn some readers away but may help others to understand and connect with the character on a different level. The story tackles many themes, mostly revolving around coming-of-age and realizing that the world is bigger than one perceives it as a child. There are also underlying commentaries on things like genetic manipulation (hint: the trees didn’t start eating people on their own), gender identity, and religion. It explored the necessity and folly of following tradition in a nuanced way that continued into the following books and while on the surface this could be read as an interesting adventure, there is also room to dig into the conflicts for the more philosophical reader. Outside of the writing style, this is an extremely accessible and overall enjoyable read.
January 2024
Land of Milk and Honey by C. Pam Zhang
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
Land of Milk and Honey, like many other climate fiction books, is set in the near future after massive fires have caused a perpetual smog to cover most of Earth’s land masses and have killed off most of humanity’s food crops. But there is a colony of the world’s elite that has managed to set up a new life on a mountaintop. The unnamed main character of this story is a chef who will do anything to get a job in this small paradise. When she arrives, she finds that the job requires much more from her than cooking and that she will learn more than recipes.
This book explores themes of identity, ambition, wealth, and survival. It pushes the boundaries of the reader and characters and explores the ethics of finding joy and pleasure in a dying world. The story takes us through the confusion and overwhelm that our protagonist feels, comparing situations to flashbacks of her life before the smog and during her time of starvation. The language and style of this book have a literary feel to them, which may make connecting to the unnamed protagonist difficult for some readers. There are often comparisons and analogies to food, flavors, and cooking techniques that keep the focus on both our chef protagonist and the setting of abundance amidst starvation. While the main character can be cynical and I would hesitate to call this book a happy one, it does leave the reader feeling hopeful for the future.
December 2023
Memory of Water by Emmi Itäranta
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
Memory of Water is set in the distant future, where water is a rare commodity. It is protected and distributed by the government through water quotas. People who commit water crimes are isolated and executed. It is never cold and bugs are a constant threat. In an area that was once called Scandinavia, we follow a teenage girl as she follows in her father’s footsteps to become a tea master. Noria Kaitio learns about the relationships of tea masters to water and of water to death, all connected and sacred in their own way. Through this training, she also learns of secrets passed on from tea master to tea master for generations, some dangerous enough to get her family killed. In her spare time, she and her friend, Sanja, scavenge the remains of a long-lost civilization to find discarded plastic and old electronics, stumbling across a secret hidden in strange silver discs that they can listen to with one of these ancient machines.
This story is very beautifully and atmospherically written. The way the author built up the world from an environmental and political perspective was both spectacular and haunting. The characters were interesting to follow and the themes of connecting water to death were used cleverly at times, but occasionally came across as a bit heavy-handed. I felt this book was setting up a fantastic story. But that was it. I felt like the author just set the story up and left it. If I hadn’t checked everywhere possible to confirm this isn’t the first book in a series, I would swear it is. There’s a lot of information, the plot introduces some wonderful questions, and everything about this book screams “potential,” but when it was over I felt both unsatisfied and disappointed. If you’re a fan of open endings, you may enjoy this book more than I did. I do think it was worth reading regardless.
November 2023
Night in the World by Sharon English
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
Night in the World features a compelling story of lives changing, growing, and intersecting as two brothers mourn their mother in very different ways and a moth biologist explores the magic of insects. The brothers, Oliver and Justin are very different people with different lives. Oliver is drifting in life, love, and career and has lacked direction completely for years while Justin is the owner of a beloved local restaurant with a wife and child. Meanwhile, Gabe is moving back to her home to pursue a graduate degree studying her passion, moths. The chapters of this book alternate between the three characters, delving deep into each and the places they value as we see how fear, frustration, drug addiction, climate activism, and questioning institutions set them on their own paths of growth. There is a motif throughout of water, how it connects people, and how each character relates, down to the chapter titles alternating between “The Island,” “The River,” and “The Lake” depending on which point of view is present.
The book itself has less of a focus on the plot and chooses to focus on atmosphere and character reflection with evocative, descriptive writing that transports the reader to the locations. I would recommend this to readers who enjoy character-driven stories, especially if those readers are curious about moth biology.
October 2023
A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter M. Miller Jr.
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
A Canticle for Leibowitz is a unique story that unfolds over centuries following what can be assumed is World War III and a massive amount of destruction wreaked on both humans and the landscape of North America. The plot follows several characters through this timespan, all linked by a religious order that values the preservation of knowledge only second to their faith while the world slowly rises from a new Dark Age. The themes of this book are focused on the value of knowledge, especially science, as well as a reflection on humankind’s darker side. There is especially a focus on ignorance, violence, and barbarism in human societies and the apparent cyclical nature of people to continue in these patterns of conflict regardless of previous consequences.
I must admit that while the writing was engaging and at times quite clever and I can not deny this was a well-written and executed book, I did not like it. However, I do not believe the intention of the book was to be particularly enjoyable. The narrative felt cynical in a way that I couldn’t enjoy, but it certainly got the author’s message across.
September 2023
The Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson
Article written by Kim Fox, ECU Sustainability Outreach Specialist
The Ministry for the Future is a book set in the near future where Kim Stanley Robinson explores the consequences of human-driven climate change and how possible solutions could play out. The narrative has several points of view that explore the changes in the climate and society’s response from different perspectives, several of which are anonymous and some even from inanimate objects. There are two main points of view that drive the narrative forward and help the reader to find a connecting point. One of these is Mary Murphy, the chair of the Ministry for the Future which is a new organization that is responsible for representing future generations that have no voice and will be affected by our actions. We see her struggles as she tries to push environmental legislation and find solutions to climate change as climate disasters are happening all around her. The second is Frank May, a young man who is a victim of one of these disasters very early in the story and thus is faced with intense grief, trauma, and survivor’s guilt. His perspectives in the book are visceral and help connect readers who may feel a sense of frustration and helplessness when it comes to climate change.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who wants to learn more about potential climate change solutions in a unique and story-driven format. While it is a work of fiction, Robinson did his research into every aspect of climate change solutions within the book from economics to glaciology. Some readers may find the more technical portions of this book tedious, so I recommend approaching the story with a mindset to learn and enjoy the narrative story along the way.